Skip to content
Jesus Christ Oil PaintingsJesus Christ Oil Paintings

Pietà, Lamentation and Entombment: What Is the Difference?

Published · Art & See editorial desk

Pietà, Lamentation and Entombment describe closely connected images after Christ’s death. They are not three perfectly sealed boxes. Museum records can use Pietà and Lamentation together, while an Entombment may also be designed to invite contemplation of the dead Christ. [1][2]

Pietà and Lamentation can overlap

Annibale Carracci’s The Dead Christ Mourned (The Three Maries), about 1604, provides a clear example. The National Gallery describes the picture as a pietà and explains it as mourning over the dead Christ. His body rests in the Virgin’s lap while other women respond to the loss. The institution’s wording allows the terms to overlap within one documented work. [1]

The painting is recorded as NG2923. Retaining that identifier and the full catalogue title is more useful than silently replacing its name with whichever thematic label a website happens to prefer. A topic heading can help explain the picture without becoming a new claim about its official title.

A dead man lies stretched across the foreground, his head against a woman who has fainted backwards into the arms of a younger one. A red-robed woman kneels at the right with both hands raised and her mouth open; an older woman in dark green leans in from behind, and a dark opening in the rock closes the background.
The National Gallery calls this picture a pietà and, in the same sentence, the lamentation over the dead Christ: the body in the Virgin's lap, the Magdalene wailing, the other women around her. [1]The National Gallery, London (NG2923). Image from the Jesus Christ Oil Paintings catalogue.

Entombment centres on carrying or burial

Michelangelo’s The Entombment (or Christ being carried to his Tomb), about 1500–1, is National Gallery inventory NG790. The Gallery identifies the action as the transport of Christ’s body towards a tomb. The picture is unfinished, and several proposed identifications of the surrounding people remain qualified rather than certain. [2]

The same record explains that the upright presentation of Christ can have a devotional function as well as a narrative one. An image may therefore describe an action and invite contemplation at the same time. “Devotional” should not be treated as the opposite of all storytelling. [2]

A pale naked body is held upright by broad strips of cloth, carried by a red-robed figure on the left and a green-robed one on the right, with a bald bearded man behind. A woman kneels at the lower left, and a large patch at the lower right is left bare and unpainted.
The action the title names: the body is being carried, not laid out for mourning. The panel was left unfinished, and the National Gallery keeps several identifications of the surrounding figures qualified. [2]The National Gallery, London (NG790). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Do not confuse removal from the Cross with burial

Ugolino di Nerio’s The Deposition, National Gallery NG3375, supplies a neighbouring episode. Here the body is being taken down from the Cross. The Gallery identifies Saint John holding Christ and places the panel in the predella of the Santa Croce altarpiece. Removal from the Cross and transport towards a tomb are successive actions, even when related works use similar mourners or gestures. [3]

Against a gold ground, a man on a ladder lowers a limp body from a wooden cross. A woman in dark blue presses her face to his, a man in crimson clutches the torso, and a kneeling man at the lower right draws a nail from the feet with pincers while blood pools on the rock below.
The body has not left the Cross yet — the nails are still coming out — and the National Gallery identifies Saint John holding Christ. Removal from the Cross and transport to the tomb are successive actions. [3]The National Gallery, London (NG3375). Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

A comparison method for uncertain titles

Ask what the figures are doing: supporting the body during removal, mourning beside it, or carrying it towards burial. Next read the institution’s title, alternate title and description. Use those together rather than judging the whole subject from one person’s pose.

Keep three questions distinct. The subject concerns the represented event or devotional theme. Identity concerns which physical artwork the record describes. Attribution concerns who made it. A disagreement over an artist does not automatically change the subject, and a shared subject does not prove that two records describe the same painting.

Four moments after the Crucifixion, told apart by what the figures are doing
SceneThe actionWhere the body isWho holds or supports itWho else is there
DepositionThe body is being taken down from the Cross; the nails are still being pulled out [3]Still at the Cross, collapsing as it comes free [3]Saint John the Evangelist clutches him and the Virgin catches him, placing her face against his [3]A man on the ladder, probably Joseph of Arimathea; a man at the feet, possibly Nicodemus; Mary Magdalene and other women [3]
PietàMourning over the dead Christ after the Crucifixion [1]At rest, lying in the Virgin's lap [1]The Virgin Mary [1]Mary Magdalene kneeling, hands raised and mouth open, with the other women [1]
LamentationThe same mourning; the National Gallery uses the word for NG2923 in the same sentence as pietà [1]At rest, in the Virgin's lap in this painting [1]The Virgin Mary in this painting [1]The women closest to Christ — whose mourning, the Gallery notes, is recounted in none of the four Gospels [1]
EntombmentThe body is carried towards the tomb [2]Held upright and carried, in Michelangelo's panel up a step towards a tomb in the rocks [2]Figures carrying him on strips of winding cloth; the Gallery's identifications stay qualified [2]A man behind Christ, either Joseph of Arimathea or Nicodemus; women on both sides [2]

Actions, positions and identifications as given in the three National Gallery records this guide cites: NG3375 for the Deposition, NG2923 for the pietà and the lamentation, NG790 for the Entombment. [1][2][3] The middle two rows describe one documented painting, not two sealed categories — that is the point of the overlap.

Sources

  1. National Gallery: Carracci, The Dead Christ Mourned, NG2923Accessed .
  2. National Gallery: Michelangelo, The Entombment, NG790Accessed .
  3. National Gallery: Ugolino di Nerio, The Deposition, NG3375Accessed .
Pietà, Lamentation and Entombment: What Is the Difference? — Jesus Christ Oil Paintings